It’s not just Google searches anymore. Patients are turning to AI assistants and browsers like ChatGPT and ChatGPT Atlas, Google Gemini, and Perplexity with its new Comet AI agent to ask:

“Who’s the best dentist near me?”

And when AI looks for answers, one of the strongest data sources it pulls from is your online reviews. In other words, your reviews are quickly becoming your AI reputation.

Here are the top review signals AI is most likely using to evaluate dentists — plus best practices for growing your reviews ethically and effectively.

---

📝 10 Review Signals That Matter Most

Signal	Why It Matters	What You Can Do
⭐ Average rating	A high average shows quality and trust.	Aim for steady 4–5★ ratings. (e.g. 5 reviews all 5★ is less convincing than 200 reviews with 4.9★).
👥 Number of reviews	More reviews = stronger proof.	Set up a system so every team member feels comfortable asking.
⏰ Recency of reviews	Fresh reviews reflect today’s patient experience.	Don’t rely on old reviews — ask at natural moments (compliments, check-outs).
📊 Consistency	A stable pattern builds trust.	Create a monthly or quarterly plan to request reviews.
💬 Review content	Detailed stories carry more weight than generic praise.	Encourage patients to share what made their visit great.
👤 Reviewer credibility	Real, active accounts are weighted higher.	Ask real patients, not out-of-town friends.
🗨️ Responses to reviews	Engaging shows professionalism.	Reply to every review, positive or negative. Always keep HIPAA in mind.
🦷 Service coverage	A range of reviews shows broad expertise.	Encourage reviews across different treatments. Or if you’re looking to attract niche procedures (implants, clear aligners, smile makeovers), invite patients to specifically mention those experiences.
📍 Local relevance	AI favors nearby providers.	Make sure your NAP (Name, Address, Phone) is consistent everywhere online.
🌐 Platform trust	Not all sites carry equal weight.	Focus on Google first, then Healthgrades, Facebook, or Yelp as secondary priorities.

---

🙌 Best Practices for Growing Reviews (Without Cringe or Risk)

Getting reviews doesn’t have to feel awkward or pushy. The best results come from authentic requests and ethical systems.

✅ Do This

• Ask at moments of delight — right after a patient says something positive.
• Make it easy — Links in texts or emails. QR codes on cards you hand out or share in goody bags.
• Use a friendly script — “We’re so glad you had a good visit! If you’d share your experience in a quick review, it helps others find us too.”
• Reply to every review — a simple “Thank you” goes a long way.
• Be consistent — ask weekly, not just when you remember.

---

🚫 Don’t Do This

I keep seeing consultants recommend incentivizing reviews and referrals. This is a hard no — it’s against FTC regulations and, honestly, it’s cringey. Incentivizing can even backfire. One hair salon was actually called out in reviews with comments like: “Don’t go there — they give bad haircuts and that’s why they’ll pay you to leave a review.” 😂

• Never incentivize reviews with discounts or gift cards. That can cross FTC and ADA ethical lines.

---

🎁 The Ethical Way: Patient Appreciation Events

Instead of direct incentives, many practices run quarterly patient appreciation drawings.

These include everyone who supports your practice — those who:

• leave reviews,
• refer friends,
• or share your office with family and colleagues.

It’s a fun, compliance-friendly way to say “thank you” to your whole patient community — without tying rewards directly to leaving a review.

Example wording:

“Thanks to all our amazing patients who support us by leaving reviews, referring friends, and spreading the word. Every quarter, we’ll celebrate you with a special patient appreciation drawing!”

---

✨ Final Thoughts

One of the most common questions I get during live presentations is:

“How do we respond to negative reviews?”

I’m happy to share this excellent resource from the American Dental Association (ADA) — a free guide covering everything you need to know about responding to both positive and negative reviews. Thank you, ADA! 🙌

AI is already shaping which dentists get recommended. By focusing on these 10 review signals — and by building a steady, ethical system for growing reviews — you’re not just boosting your online reputation, you’re future-proofing your practice.

Start today: ask one happy patient for a review. Over time, those small, steady actions will add up to a powerful AI-ready reputation.

💡 You might also like:
Why Dentists Must Rethink Search: AI, Authenticity, And The End Of Stock Photos